The Belle of Gulf Boulevard and I drove in to the Lobster's parking lot a little before four yesterday and parked our trusty Chevy in a near empty lot. I should point out that the parking lot didn't stay empty for long. We had arrived ahead of the throngs of dinner diners who soon began pouring in.
My bride and I were immediately greeted and seated. We had a choice of indoor or outdoor dining. Josh, who would be our most gracious server, suggested an outdoor table that remains cooler as the afternoon wanes. Ice water was served and our drink orders taken, a Stella draught for me and a Kendall-Jackson Chard for she. In addition to beer and wine Lobster has a well stocked full bar.
I was pleased to see Blue Point oysters on the Starters menu and in a more tactful way asked Josh if the shuckers knew what they were doing. Josh assured me that the Lobster would treat me right with freshly shucked oysters that had not been dipped in a bowl of nasty water (I have seen that done at other venues). The Lobster's shuckers, Josh stated, would present the oysters on a fresh bed of ice with the oyster meat loosened from the bottom shell and the liquor retained - as ordained by the oyster shuckers bible.
Those oysters were so salty and delicious that I had to request another half dozen. Josh confided that the shuckers were so impressed that a customer really knew oysters that they rewarded me with two extra, gratis. That was a great compliment and exceptional customer service.
My bride contented herself watching me scarfing down my oysters while she waited for her Fish and Chips.
The haddock prepared with a beer batter was crispy on the outside and cooked to flavorful perfection on the inside. The chips (a.k.a. fries) were homemade, not store bought, and were excellent.
Since I was dining at Lucky Lobster Co. it just made sense to order a steamed lobster - so I did. I asked Josh about presentation and he said I could have my lobster served any way that pleased me. Heavens to Murgatroid, superior customer service reared its head again!
I prefer my steamed lobster presented with the head on so that I might enjoy the goodies waiting within. The tasty green stuff is the tomalley (from the Carib word tumale, meaning a sauce of lobster liver). Obviously my Lucky Lobster wasn't so lucky, but it was really good ... and rich. My sides included perfectly steamed veggies and those crispy and delicious fries.
The beer was cold, the wine was served at the proper temperature, and the food was extremely satisfying. As good as the comestibles were, the service provided by Josh was exemplary. I would go back to Lucky Lobster just to enjoy Josh's company and conversation.
All food and several adult beverages came to a pleasing $120. The Piglet Parade highly recommends this Dunedin eatery.